Author: admin

  • God, Cognitive Humility and Being Able to say “Wonderful!”

    DSC02259

    "Now. Which way is Africa? Think it might be south. Time to look out the passport, pack and check in."

    There was a time when the miracle of migrating swallows would have made us wonder, and maybe even restore our fading capacity for wonder. But what the heck, what's so remarkable about a built in sat-nav? There's one in most cars nowadays.

    Precisely. We've got so used to our own cleverness, we hardly register the wonders around us. I've been wondering about that word – wonder. It ranges from curiosity to awe, and describes mental processes that are include slowed down thought, inner questioning and that head-shaking humility that gladly confesses something is, well, wonderful.

    So when I saw this swallow on the weather vane at Pitmedden House, around 8.30 on a late summer evening, it was a gently religious moment. "Even the sparrow finds a home and the swallow builds her nest near your altar…", the Psalmist pointed out to God, not that God was unaware of this. Ever since my childhood on Ayrshire farms I've admired these wee birds – their speed and agility in flight, the craftsmanship of a nest made of hundreds of mud balls, held together by woven straw and lined with feathers, built into eaves, and with an entry door the size of a 10p piece. And it flies to southern Africa, 200 miles per day, at speeds up to 35mph. Makes you wonder – well, doesn't it.

    We begin to lose an intellectual naivete essential to the health of our souls when we are no longer easily moved to wonder, when the surfeit of novelty and stimulus from elsewhere dulls the ears and blurs the eyes, and when our inner selves become so self-absorbed that the selfie matters more than the landscape, and my image displaces my substance. The irony of the photo lies, perhaps, in the fact that it's we postmodern sophisticates who are unsure of who we are, where we are, and where we are going, not the swallow – she knows, she just knows. In that sense, as a follower of Jesus, this photo gives food for thought, and I get the Psalmist's wise naivete – "even the swallow builds her nest, feels at home, takes up residence, near your altar."

    "Worship is a way of seeing the world in the light of God." (Heschel) And in the end, worship leads to wonder just as wonder leads to worship. Charles Wesley loved the word wonder, it occurs all over the place in his hymns. Perhaps the most famous speaks of the fulfilment of that cognitive humility mentioned earlier, when in the beatific vision we are "lost in wonder, love and praise."

     

     

  • Herrick’s God’s Mercy. A Poem – and a Reflection.

    DSC02339This is one of my favourite poems, but from a poet I don't much get on with. I've got a wee soft leather bound Victorian book called Devotional Poets of the 17th Century, and Herrick gets most pages ahead of Donne, Herbert, Vaughan, Crashaw and Traherne. Nowadays I guess 17th Century devotional poetry should be labelled with the nutritional traffic light system. Too sentimental sweet like ladles of condensed milk, too many degree of difficulty semantic gymnastics, too spiritually voyeuristic of others and narcissistic of the inner self with an unhealthy fascination with personal spiritual performance….and so on. 

    Certainly, compared with modern religious poetry, the seventeenth century spoke to a a different world, one that seems a solar system or two distant from where we all live now. The leading devotional poets of the 17th Century were coming to terms with civil war and new approaches to military tactics, weaponry and political possibilities beyond absolute monarchy and bloody conflict. It's the difference between the newly effective musket volley, and the laser guided bomb and uranium enriched shell and flechette and cluster bombs. Forget globalisation, they were only discovering the extent of the world, its place in our own solar system post Copernicus, and centuries ahead the importance of international co-operation in economics, collaboration of resources and knowledge in science, technological exploitation of the earth, and capacities for communication that were simply unimaginable. Think Cromwell using social media to make the case against the King, or the international media reporting regicide and a generation later the Restoration.

    And yet. Even Herrick, when he got it right, wrote about God in words that still make sense, at least theologically. That's why Herrick's poem on God's Boundless Mercy is such a favourite, because at their best, some of those old 17th C poems give richness to our praise, images to our worship, and a rootedness in the sacraments of creation which communicate the depths of God beyond words.  

    Maybe it's living beside the North Sea, replenished up here by two rivers, but this poem works for me:

    God's boundless mercy is, to sinful man,
    Like to the ever-wealthy ocean:
    Which though it sends forth thousand streams, 'tis ne'er
    Known, or else seen, to be the emptier;
    And though it takes all in, 'tis yet no more
    Full, and fill'd full, than when full fill'd before.

    DSC01223 (1)

  • Pylons, Churches and the Cross – and a nearly perfect hymn!

    One of my favourite walking or running paths takes me past the new Episcopal church in Westhill. An ultra modern, multi-purpose community building that now sits on the outskirts of the town, looking towards the distant hills of Clachnaben and Cairn O Mount.

    At one point walking past I had one of those moments when random impressions and ideas, past thoughts and inner conversation, all come together and coalesce in an image. I took the camera this morning on my more causal take it easy walk with occasional bursts of slow jogging. So I took this  picture

      DSC02322

    The juxtaposition of pylon and cross, both made of steel, both based on the intersection of horizontal and vertical, and, in Christian theology both charged with power to transform and energise – these are some thoughts that coalesce in this image, at least as I saw it. "This the power, of the cross…." is one of the established and rightly more durable songs from the Townsend collection. It affirms in strong language and a powerful and singable tune, the Christian conviction that in the cross we see not the weakness but the power of God made perfect through weakness.

    The violent imperial repression of ideas Rome feared, made the cross the chosen instrument of control by terror – when it comes to terrorism no one is better placed to terrorise than the powerful holders of weapons, power and ideology. Then as now. But the framing of the cross against the background of pylons suggests one or more reflections on green theology, the cost to the earth of our energy hunger, the ruining of creation by our manufacturing and consumptive obsessions. And yet. The renewal of creation lies at the centre of the Christian vision of the future; the earth groans awaiting its redemption, creation is about more than human beings, and redemption is about more, much more, than my wee precious unique and eternal soul!

    Which is my main hesitation with one line of Townsend's brilliant hymn; I cannot sing "Oh to see my name, written in his wounds…For in your suffering I am free." Not because it isn't true, but because it isn't the most important truth about the cross. Should any of us who have begun to understand the scale and depth of the love of God ever ever be comfortable with the first person singular "I" as the centre of our understanding of the Gospel? Oh to see the wounds of my brothers and sisters in Northern Iraq….. Oh to see Gaza's wounds and Israel's wounds and the wounded earth, and "Oh to see the famished dehydrated children of so many nations…Oh to see their names, written in your wounds, for through your suffering they are free…"

    Yes the cross is personal, because God has made the renewal of creation, the redemption of his purposes, the freeing of all creation, yes including me, personal. And yes I am invited to embrace that love, to engage that purpose, to surrender to that vision, to give in by giving myself away to this ridiculously extravagant and scandalous God whose Love dares to be crucified and defy the powers of empires that terrorise. "Death is crushed to death, life is mine to live, won through your selfless love…" He dies that those who live might no longer live for themselves but for Him who died for them and was raised again.

    This the power of the cross! That photo makes the connection. Every time I run past this church, from the downward slope I see this image, power and love. In that one line Townsend's hymn, in seeking to make it personal, in my view steps over the line of allowing our personal experience of blessing to eclipse the scale of what took place on the cross. Oh to see their names, our names, all names, written in his wounds….This the power of the cross. That I think restores the scale and eteranl perspective of the Gospel.

    Here's a couple of pictures of Westhill Episcopal Church

    DSC02333 DSC02323

     

  • The Things You Discover When Walking Off the Beaten Track

    DSC00554I've added another typelist on the sidebar, "Off the Beaten Track". This will list books outside my main interest areas, but which have been worth spending time reading, and thinking about. Once I've read each one I'll try to distill into 200 words what made it a worthwhile read. It's my age I'm sure, lending urgency to hours that increase in value year on year, so if a book I start doesn't grab me by the ankles it's just as likely to be kindly placed in the first charity bag that comes through the letter box.

    Some of the best things I've read have been in books that found me, or tugged at my sleeve, or propositioned me at a weak moment, or grabbed me by the ankles on the first page. Gillian Clarke's At the Source, was first heard on Radio 4, and the Welsh National Poet's voice and the beauty of her descriptive prose got me clicking on amazon. Conversations with Chaim Potok, brought me into the company of a novelist I've read repeatedly, but who had remained elusive as a person – he is a fascinating conversationalist on his own novels, which takes a bit of doing. Often the writer isn't the best person to say why you should read their work. Michael Foley's The Age of Absurdity is an impressively wise and shrewd account of our culture's capacity to be blind to our own stupidity. Kathleen Norris wrote Dakota as an account of her own spirituality and gave it the subtitle A Spiritual Geography. This is a hard to pin down book – topography and spirituality, observations on climate and the flora and fauna of the Great Plains, her Benedictine predilections and her work as a poet, a wife and an erstwhile yet persistent Christian, – these are all explored against the landscape of the Midwest. Matthew Guerriri wrote The First Four Notes as a historical investigation into how the first four notes of Beethoven's 5th Symphony have captured the imagination and influenced its hearers in literature, history, politics and much else in human reflection and action. 

    One of the best pieces of advice I was ever given was to make sure I read beyond my interests, my competences and my imagined areas of expertise. And I always have – that isn't a self-promoting assertion, more a self-deprecating comment of indebtedness. Because some of the most important thoughts I have thunk, some of the most interesting vistas opened in my mind, some of the more telling criticisms of my too easily arrived at certainties, have come from those "off the beaten track books". I start with Moving to Higher Ground. How Jazz Can Change Your Life, Wynton Marsalis – a book endorsed by the late and wonderful Maya Angelou.

    Not sure how long this will run for; in my mother's phrase, used as a slow let-down alternative to a straight 'no', "we'll see"! The photo shows you some of the beauty discovered, the interest provoked, the previously unencountered viewpoints attained, and the different horizons opened up, when you walk off the beaten track and read something just for the Heaven of it.

  • Where there is no vision and all that? When Visions Are Not Fit For Purpose!

    I get tired of the word vision. Whether it's in a personal development seminar, or a question about the future of the organisation, or the word wheeled out in the church community to help us be more forward, outward, upward and not backward looking – the word wearies me. It seems to suggest that the way things are is never enough. It invites, or rather demands, that I look for ways to make things different, to see things in a new way; it is a word that seems to work best in a place where there is already discontent, where the status quo is not enough.

    I know, "Where there is no vision the people perish…." and all that. Leaving aside the risks of simply yanking those words from their biblical context, there is nothing intrinsically good about a vision. It depends on whose vision it is, the content and motivation, the energy and resources, and even the level of achievability implied in the vision statements.

    Oh yes we need vision. I'm not weary of those inner longings of the heart, those spiritual flights of imagination that take us to possible new places. I'm not tired of the hard work of thinking, praying, conversing, arguing, planning and formulating new ideas, that push us towards a new way of seeing the world, creating ideas that inspire, energise, and give cohesion to communities hungering and thirsting after righteousness; such hungering and thirsting I take to mean wanting a world made more right, thirsting for an economics made more just, feeling hunger pangs for a community determinedly more porous to others, a view of people of other faiths not as enemies, or rivals, or competitors (the language of combative economics again), but communities whose vision is shaped and expanded, contained and fulfilled in filled-fulness by Jesus who goes before us. I mean giving first place to Jesus in whom the fullness of God dwells, through whom God seeks the reconciliation of all things, whose crucifixion is our call to carry the cross, whose "Follow me" remains our categorical imperative, and whose resurrection bursts the bounds of possibility in all our vision making – He is the One who is ahead of us, who is the fons et origo of every transformative vision we can think of, and the One who urges us beyond every vision statement we can formulate. 

    DSC01011It's the devaluing of the word vision I guess that makes me weary. We use the word for the latest good ideas; or the in fashion ways of doing things; or as the word that claims the high ground for our own plans and agendas. And we do this in churches, the very place where Jesus crucified and risen is the Head of all things. Unless our visions aspire towards that great vision of a healed creation, a reconciled universe, a new reality defined by shalom and pervaded by a love deeper than the abysses of our own dreaming and more durable than our own hopes, then they will run out of fuel before they even reach the edges of what we hope for.

    Vision is related to a theology of hope. Vision is what happens when we think with God on the horizon. Vision is such impatience with the status quo that nothing less than faith in the One who says "Behold I make all things new", will come within range of our longed for possibilities. For me Gaza has been an exercise in both realism and hopefulness; realism because I've no idea how to prevent that vicious, lethal cycle of hate from exploding again; hopefulness because I refuse, as a Christian steadfastly refuse, to cede the field to the powers that be, whoever they are.

    TanksAgainst the benchmarks of ancient hatred, political determinism, iron-clad vested interests, idolatry of the bomb and the gun and the rocket and the tank, discourse which sanitises evil with the vocabulary of collateral damage, human shields and terrorist madness, against all those as a Christian I do not rail, I pray. And I envision, not within the so limited scale of my own thinking and hoping and longing, but within the great vision of the Gospel of peace and reconciliation. I dare to believe that the Holy Spirit is God's self-gift to the world, moving with renewing and redeeming power within the structures of what we call reality; that Jesus Christ embodies the love and mercy of God taking on the worst the world can do, and emerging through suffering to resurrection which contradicts all that our human worst can do; that God's purposes for his creation are purposes that are ultimately, finally and irrevocably redemptive.

    Maybe, just maybe, as well as all the practical things we desperately try to do – from buying Palestinian oil to speaking with our Jewish friends; from gift aid to charities committed to shalom purposes to making sure we are informed enough to take on the nonsense and sometimes dangerous nonsense spoken around us – as well as these, being a faithful follower of the crucified risen Jesus means being realistic about the worlds we live in – a world where crucifixion was not final, and resurrection realised the impossible possibility that death and the dealers of death don;t have the last word. 

     

  • Thoughts on Retirement and What I’m Going to Do with My Self.

    "So how are you enjoying retirement?"  "What do you do with yourself these days?""Got any plans?"

    These are tricky questions. Not because they are meant to be but because of the assumptions that shape them. At first I resisted the denominator "retired", because I have no intention of retiring just yet. But that sounds like incipient denial, I'm not that old….yet! But it isn't that. It's to do with an underlying vocational pull towards those so varied areas of life and those diversities of gifts and the always to be looked for opportunities which together with inner motives and accumulated experience make up my life past, my life present and life into whatever future lies within the purposes of God.

    Now that last phrase is the important one; "within the purposes of God". What I do with myself these days isn't the straightforward question those who ask it (with kindness and interest) think that it is! What I do with myself is an even more interesting phrase if I simply insert a space – What I do with my self. Over the years I've tried to resist the assumption that what we do defines who we are. So on Facebook I am a former College Principal, but I'm also a former and present Baptist minister; a husband, a father, a friend, a brother. I'm a writer, a scholar, a preacher, a gardener, a reader – I do tapestry, take photos, cook the most amazing lasagne, rice puddings and Moroccan chicken. All of these I do with my self, and as I do them, the self that I am changes and grows.

    What I have found as I've thought about all this during a two month sabbatical is that what every one of us has done in all these layers and episodes of life, has been and goes on being the raw material out of which, day by day, we are being shaped and formed into who we are becoming. That present continuous "becoming", should warn us against a fixed, static definition of who we are; we are more than what we have done, and our identity is a dynamic, growing but changing continuity held together by our choices, decisions, circumstances seen and unforeseen, and that nexus of relationships with all those folk who move in and out of our lives. 

    Vocation is an important way of living our lives; it has for me a defining Christian urgency. I am called to be me, but a self committed to following Jesus faithfully, living under the rule of Christ. That's true whether I'm preaching or cooking, laying turf in my garden or taking a funeral, stitching and working a tapestry or accompanying people in their lives as they try to discern and live into the patterns and purposes of God. You don't retire from what is a chosen way of life, and whatever else Christian faith is, it is a Way, a way of life we have both chosen and to which we have been called.

    So what am I doing with my self these days? Taking time to think, to let the last few years settle and begin to fit into a life lived self-consciously Godward, with more or less understanding of what that means. These words of C S Lewis have helped me to trust God's creative faithfulness, and to believe that it is the grace of God, often undetected at the time, that slowly or quickly, gently or fiercely, persistently and patiently, works away at the envisioned objet d'art that is each one of us :

    "All that you are…every fold and crease of your individuality was devised from all eternity to fit God as a glove fits a hand. All that intimate particularity which you can hardly grasp yourself, much less communicate to your fellow creatures, is no mystery to Him. He made those ins and outs that he might fill them. Then he gave you a soul so curious a life because it is a key designed to unlock that door, of all the myriad doors in Him."

    DSC02296
    The photo is of one of our roses,another unique presence, called and created to be beautiful for a while……

  • The Disconnect of Living in Two Worlds – Glasgow and Gaza

    Has anyone else found it really diifcult to live in two media worlds at once these past weeks?

    Fireworks

    The Commonwealth Games have brought enormous energy, enjoyment, achievement and social cohesion; for which read a pervasive in your face friendliness from Glasgow people that is infectious, funny and incurably self-conscious without being anything other than glad to host the party and include everybody within loud shouting distance. The interviews with Glasgow folk are a credit to a city that knows its own history, and knows its own place, and is proud of both. Glasgow has been a whirring hub of life engaged in making a big thing happen and doing it in a way that is peculiarly Glaswegian and memorably Scottish. (Apart from not including the Proclaimers in the closing ceremony – what a missed opportunity that was!! 

    From such humming euphoria, high visibility human togetherness, days of shared laughter and hopes, international cross cultural goodwill, we turn to the news from Gaza. That shift of focus has required a bewildering change of worldview, a psychological decompression chamber lest we absorb so much tragedy and suffering into minds that need time to adjust. The number dead has reached 1800 with 9,000 injured, the vast majority civilians. Another 10 died yesterday, taking shelter from the sun, under a tree, at the gate of a UN run school sheltering several thousand civilians.

    The media constructed alternative worlds are truly bewildering and heartbreaking. Lifetime challenge and ambitions of atheltes, and the life destroying goals of Hamas and Israel; sport as a medium of friendship, and conflict as the nursery of future hatred, enmity and violence; the exchange of shuttlecocks, hockey balls, contrasts with crude rockets and flechette shells, drone missiles and precision air strikes; finish lines and endurance races, contrast with conflict borderlines and the endurance of a people with nowhere to go as the lines of lethal advance concentrate their numbers and the high explosive ordnance keeps raining.

    I admit it. I am bewildered, emotionally and morally unsettled, not sure what to think, or do or say. Images of fireworks celebrating our human togetherness keep being contradicted by images of explosions and flashes of fire as death is dealt with computer precision. These past weeks have been so wonderful for Glasgow, so hellish for Gaza. So I do what I can; I sign the petitions; I blog and write to my MP and I argue with the "Israel can do no wrong lobby", and I pray. But none of that makes any visible difference to the inflicted misery and eclipse of mercy that is Israel and Gaza at war.

    One of the most remarkable advances in human behaviour and social hopefulness was the establishing of the lex talionis principle, an eye for an eye and a tooth for a tooth. No that is not a licence for vengeance, it is an imposed constraint upon hatred, an agreed control of violence, a crude but essential justice based on proportionality, and with the intention that such exchange is limited to the offender and the offended. The collective punishment of the Palestinian people lacks all proportionality, has no relation whatsoever to justice, makes no pretence at limitation and is made worse not better by rhetoric about seeking to avoid civilian casualties when the numbers are as they are.

    But then, this is the 21st Century, we know better than the ancients, our sophisticated weaponry doesn't require us to personally kill each person – that can be done remotely, more efficiently and with greater killing power. And when one protagonist couldn't care less about the lives of its own population, then the provocation takes on lethal persistence; and when the other protagonist has overwhelming military capacity to inflict death at will, it can be done with impunity until the international bystanding stops. And whether I like it or not, British arms sales to Israel make me implicit; and our Government's supine silence makes me ashamed; but I pray the Lord's Prayer, and believe in its hopefulness, its defiance of those who think their Kingdom is unshakeable and their will is to be done.

  • Re-Reading Brueggemann 1. When, if ever, is the Church Not the Church?

    51vYl9sxusLI'm re-reading my loose leaf paperback of Walter Brueggemann, Texts Under Negotiation. The Bible and Postmodern Imagination. It's 20 years old, I've read it twice before, the glue has dried and it's now bound with a rubber band. The past week I've spoken with a number of folk for whom the church is a problem, or an irrelevance, or a menace. When the church becomes obsessed with ethical arguments about sexuality, or fails to speak with any authoritative, joined up and consistent voice about the genocide in Gaza, or appears so timid and morale poor in the face of its own declining clout in a culture that's moved on without a backward look, then it;s time for Christians to ask the question: 'What on earth is the church for?' Ecclesiology draws its coherence from an adequate Christology – of all communities with a voice in our culture, the church should at least be clear about who Jesus is, why Jesus matters, and the difference Jesus makes when as living presence of God a community embodies the redeeming, reconciling , renewing and pervasively subverting presence of the resurrected Lord. 

    At least, that's what I think, and I'm heartened when I read a book I first read 20 years ago to find that underlined passages retain their power to encourage such thinking, strengthen such hoping, and give impetus to those desires and prayers that long for the church to be the church Jesus calls it to be, and stop trying to be the church Christians say it should be, or others expect it to be. So here is Walter's ecclesiologically clued up comment, as relevant now as then:

    The church as an alternative community in the world is not a "voluntary association", an accident of human preference. The church as a wedge of newness, as a foretaste of what is coming, as a home for the odd ones, is the work of God's originary mercy. For all its distortedness, the church peculiarly hosts God's power of life.

    The church in a quite special way is the place where large dreams are entertained, songs are sung, boundaries are crossed, hurt is noticed, and the weak are honored. The church has no monopoly on these matters. Its oddity, however, is that it takes this agenda as its peculiar and primary business. In all sorts of unnoticed places, it is the church that raises the human questions."

    I wish I could have said this about the church, knowing it to be evident and true, to the three people sitting next to us at the Sand Dollar on the Aberdeen front, delightfully and courteously questioning why I was a minister; and to the couple I spoke with at the interval at Pitmedden Garden the other night about the horrors of Gaza; and to my friend for whom the church, not the Gospel, is a scandal.

    As it is, Brueggemann's hopeful imagination enables me to look at the church, and persist in believing that what he says is true.

     

  • Ordinary pictures in ordinary time….

    DSC02231

    Just now and again the juxtaposition of images is unsettling. Walking by this field of ready to harvest barley the barbed wire was at eye level – that path was lower than the field, please note!

    The grain that nourishes – by the way, although barley is used for brewing, it's also a staple ingredient of Scotch Broth – is fenced in by tight parallel lines of sharpened steel.

    Barbed wire is to keep in or keep out. It has its uses but by definition and design it does its work by fear or hurt. A reminder of the serious issues facing our qworld where grain and steel, food and defence, nourishment and threat, co-exist.

    DSC02234-1Then there's the moment the bee and the flower come together. Honey is the result of that more creative juxtaposition. Looking across St Cyrus bay, the micro drama of honey making plays out against a background of windswept dunes, distant sea and cliffs for a mile northwards.

    Now, what's the flower? Is it a field scabious? In any case, one of my joys of walking with a camera is for just those moments of happening, when nothing unusual happens, except that I am there to see it, and paying enough attention not to miss it!

    DSC02253


    .

     

     

    At Pitmedden open air Shakespeare and with time at the interval to enjoy the garden in late July sunlight. I love mature trees with a shape formed over years of weather, husbandry and growth mapped to context. This tree wouldn't have grown just like this, anywhere else. And over decandes pushing towards a century it has slowly spread and accommodated itself so that it looks just right.

    Three photographs, entirely incidental, lacking any lasting significance, except for the presence of the photographer who notices, bothers and sees….

     

  • Mr Netanyahu and the corrosive mindset of mercilessness.

    _76593143_76591827

    These are the words of broken hearted Jewish people:

    Remember O Lord against the Edomites
    the day of Jerusalem’s fall.,

    How they said “Tear it down. Tear it down.
    Down to its foundations.”

    O daughter Babylon, you devastator!
    Happy shall they be who pay you back
    what you have done to us.
    Happy shall they be who take your little ones
    and dash them against rocks.

    These horrendous, brutal, anguished words came from people who could no longer find acceptable words to describe what had befallen them at the hands of a more powerful enemy. The bitter irony of the events in Gaza is that the very people from whose national suffering and shattering such words of imprecation came, are engaged in actions which create precisely the same future-looking rage, and hunger for vengeance, that make these words so chillingly potent.

    So in answer to Mr Netanyahu’s speech about preparing for a protracted operation (for which read more killing of innocent civilians), I remind him of the words of the Jewish people, his people, against Edomites and that a simple word change makes the same overwhelming moral case:
    How he said, “Tear it down. Tear it down. Down to its foundations.”

    And the response of a broken people, brutalised by overwhelming military force, “O Israel, you devastator!”

    The Israeli military rhetoric behind the Gaza assaults will inevitably mean those last verses from a Jewish Psalm, are now being said by Palestinian mothers, fathers and children. They have seen their children and parents dashed to pieces by merciless unremitting salvos of military ordnance, sold and manufactured in the UK and US. Overwhelming grief left unassuaged, and violence unleashed with assumed impunity, normalise the mind-set of the merciless. That is what I detected in Mr Netanyahu’s speech last night. Not political obstinacy, though that too; not justified anger and grievance, though that is also granted. But a merciless dismissal of intolerable suffering of those who have no recourse, or defence. Mercilessness is a corrosive mindset, and a contagious and lethal virus. And a world that stands by and sees it take hold, and says nothing and does nothing effectively to end the carnage, shares the guilt and responsibility for the spread of toxins into a bleak future.

    Tanks

    These tank shells are dragon's teeth; they are also merchandise traded around the world as if they were as ordinary and necessary as daily bread.