a kind of boring tune….but cool words

On a Sunday recently I was preaching for the first time at one of our churches. Renewed friendships with several people I seem to bump into only every few years – to my loss, and perhaps their relief. Nah, they like me too!

As in many churches now, worship was led by others and I was only required to preach – I didn’t choose the hymns, though my text and theme were known to those preparing the worship service. The closing hymn was introduced unpromisingly as having a kind of boring tune, but the words were judged to be ‘cool’. Two things – ONE. I am well impressed with worship leaders who give enough weight to the beauty of words, so that at times a tune can be secondary. TWO – this hymn was by a country mile the best hymn we sang all morning, in the humble but not muted opinion of this preacher.

The words are reproduced below.It appears in a number of hymn books – there will now be a rant on behalf of the Regrettable Demise of the Hymn Book party – [Hymn books – remember those ancient artifacts, they tend to be square, with hard or soft covers, churches had enough of them so that everyone got one, and between the covers there are sheets of paper printed on both sides with numbered appropriate things to sing, part of the intention being that a manageable number of hymns (appropriate things to sing at worship) would be known by the whole congregation and not require performing praise bands to praise God on behalf of a congregation once again patiently learning this cool praise song by miming words that have little rhythm, beauty of arrangement, metaphorical resonance, memorable rhetoric, in which bathos displaces pathos, and emotional me-centred feel good singing eclipses adoration rooted in the sense of God’s mighty love in Christ – which yes makes me feel good] – rant ended…..for now.

This hymn could stand being sung as often as some Baptist churches have communion – First  and third Sunday of the month in the morning and last Sunday of the month in the evening. It was an inspired choice, and I am grateful to the worship leader for overcoming personal taste in music to include ‘cool words’ and bring a worship service to that place of response where we all, in thepresence of God, covenant together to love and serve each other, in church and world, in the name of Jesus.

Brother, sister, let me serve you

  let me be as Christ to you:

pray that I may have the grace to

  let you be my servant too.

.

We are pilgrims on a journey

  and companions on the road;

we are here to help each other

  walk the mile and bear the load.

.

I will hold the Christ-light for you

  in the night time of your fear;

I will hold my hand out to you

  speak the peace you long to hear.

.

I will weep when you are weeping

  when you laugh I’ll laugh with you;

I will share your joy and sorrow

  till we’ve seen this journey through.

.

When we sing to God in heaven

  we shall find such harmony,

born of all we’ve known together

  of Christ’s love and agony.

.

Brother, sister, let me serve you

  let me be as Christ to you:

pray that I may have the grace to

  let you be my servant too.

Richard Gillard, Baptist Praise and Worship, number 473.

Comments

14 responses to “a kind of boring tune….but cool words”

  1. Catriona avatar
    Catriona

    This is one of the favourites in my little church, but then I guess we are a bit old famgled.
    I found two good reasons for moving away from hymnbooks…
    1) It avoids ‘hymnbook wars’ that great English Baptist game where later must be better and Songs of Fellowship book 257 trumps Mission Praise Super Extra Complete with Supplement etc etc. Now I will regularly draw from three or four books a week to find the things that fit best.
    2) It allows a few word tweaks for inclusive language -for example in Songs of fellowship the hymn above is (spit) ‘Brother, let me be your servant.’ Although I’ve been teased about some of my clumsy word tweaks, it’s hardly fair to blame the male of the species for all every sin or deceit is it? 😉
    A third reason for us is that even large print Baptist Praise and Worship is so small that half my folk can’t see it!
    Lastly, to whoever said the tune to ‘brother, sister’ was boring – I like it!

  2. Catriona avatar
    Catriona

    This is one of the favourites in my little church, but then I guess we are a bit old famgled.
    I found two good reasons for moving away from hymnbooks…
    1) It avoids ‘hymnbook wars’ that great English Baptist game where later must be better and Songs of Fellowship book 257 trumps Mission Praise Super Extra Complete with Supplement etc etc. Now I will regularly draw from three or four books a week to find the things that fit best.
    2) It allows a few word tweaks for inclusive language -for example in Songs of fellowship the hymn above is (spit) ‘Brother, let me be your servant.’ Although I’ve been teased about some of my clumsy word tweaks, it’s hardly fair to blame the male of the species for all every sin or deceit is it? 😉
    A third reason for us is that even large print Baptist Praise and Worship is so small that half my folk can’t see it!
    Lastly, to whoever said the tune to ‘brother, sister’ was boring – I like it!

  3. jim gordon avatar

    I know Catriona, and I am not a liturgical luddite. In response – hymn-book wars are like the 20th century claims that war between the superpowers was avoided after 1945. It wasn’t – it was displaced to other developing regions. likewise, if not hymn-book wars then worship wars. You are absolutely right about having to tweak words – but that is an editing problem for book compilers who should have enough gender balance on their committees to ensure gender balance in the book! And print-size – I suppose that’s one of the practical down sides of print – but big screens aint too much fun for arthritic necks, or 5 foot four inch worshippers stuck behind the big folk in front.
    As David Frost would say of the hymn I refer to, ‘But it is, is it not, a fine hymn. You would, would you not, agree.
    How’s Malachi doing – did you get that commentary

  4. jim gordon avatar

    I know Catriona, and I am not a liturgical luddite. In response – hymn-book wars are like the 20th century claims that war between the superpowers was avoided after 1945. It wasn’t – it was displaced to other developing regions. likewise, if not hymn-book wars then worship wars. You are absolutely right about having to tweak words – but that is an editing problem for book compilers who should have enough gender balance on their committees to ensure gender balance in the book! And print-size – I suppose that’s one of the practical down sides of print – but big screens aint too much fun for arthritic necks, or 5 foot four inch worshippers stuck behind the big folk in front.
    As David Frost would say of the hymn I refer to, ‘But it is, is it not, a fine hymn. You would, would you not, agree.
    How’s Malachi doing – did you get that commentary

  5. Catriona avatar
    Catriona

    Hi Jim, sorry, wasn’t meaning to suggest you were a luddite – and at 5’4″ myself I know all about tall people and screens. Nothing is right for everyone is it? I even have odd moments of wondering if the anti-singing C17 Baptists had something right after all…!
    Malachi – coming up this Sunday. If you posted the library book, I’m worried as it hasn’t appeared; hope it’s not lost in the post. The one I ordered from Amazon arrived yesterday. I think I’m looking forward to preaching on it – it has certainly made me think, and that’s got to be good.

  6. Catriona avatar
    Catriona

    Hi Jim, sorry, wasn’t meaning to suggest you were a luddite – and at 5’4″ myself I know all about tall people and screens. Nothing is right for everyone is it? I even have odd moments of wondering if the anti-singing C17 Baptists had something right after all…!
    Malachi – coming up this Sunday. If you posted the library book, I’m worried as it hasn’t appeared; hope it’s not lost in the post. The one I ordered from Amazon arrived yesterday. I think I’m looking forward to preaching on it – it has certainly made me think, and that’s got to be good.

  7. jim gordon avatar

    the book you ordered is the same as the one I said is in our library. I relaised this when we exchanged notes recently. Sorry – should have told you then you wouldn’t have been looking for a non posted book! Hope you preach well and they bring the tithes in!
    Shalom, Jim

  8. jim gordon avatar

    the book you ordered is the same as the one I said is in our library. I relaised this when we exchanged notes recently. Sorry – should have told you then you wouldn’t have been looking for a non posted book! Hope you preach well and they bring the tithes in!
    Shalom, Jim

  9. Catriona avatar
    Catriona

    Nae problem, as you’d say in bonnie Scotland.

  10. Catriona avatar
    Catriona

    Nae problem, as you’d say in bonnie Scotland.

  11. Andy avatar
    Andy

    I like this hymn too – Sarah and I sung it at our wedding. It seems to me that it makes a good baptismal hymn too. The tune is fine too, particularly if you rely on a single pianist rather than a band.
    I echo many of your other comments too about the modern stuff. Having said that there are some wonderful hymns still being written. I recently received my annual package of new hymns from Timothy Dudley-Smith, whilst Martin Leckebusch (a Baptist if I’m not mistaken)has written some first rate stuff. With respect to hymn/song books. My favourite is Sing Glory, published by Kevin Mayhew in 1999, a wonderfully eclectic mix including some wonderful modern hymns. Sadly, I have yet to discover a church that actually uses it. Still, I can mine it for gems to introduce to my congregation here.
    As for hymnbooks/song books.

  12. Andy avatar
    Andy

    I like this hymn too – Sarah and I sung it at our wedding. It seems to me that it makes a good baptismal hymn too. The tune is fine too, particularly if you rely on a single pianist rather than a band.
    I echo many of your other comments too about the modern stuff. Having said that there are some wonderful hymns still being written. I recently received my annual package of new hymns from Timothy Dudley-Smith, whilst Martin Leckebusch (a Baptist if I’m not mistaken)has written some first rate stuff. With respect to hymn/song books. My favourite is Sing Glory, published by Kevin Mayhew in 1999, a wonderfully eclectic mix including some wonderful modern hymns. Sadly, I have yet to discover a church that actually uses it. Still, I can mine it for gems to introduce to my congregation here.
    As for hymnbooks/song books.

  13. Andy avatar
    Andy

    Woops sorry about the last line which I had intended to delete. I knew I should have previewed first!

  14. Andy avatar
    Andy

    Woops sorry about the last line which I had intended to delete. I knew I should have previewed first!

Leave a Reply to Catriona Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *